Libertarian View of Justice – Robert Nozick – Jurisprudence Notes

Spread the love

Objection to redistribution of wealth:-

o   Reduces incentive to work and overall decreasing wealth and consequentially utility of redistribution (Utilitarian Argument)
o   Redistribution without consent amounts to coercion (Libertarian View)

  • Favour unrestricted markets and oppose government regulation not on grounds of efficiency but human freedom
  • Supports minimal state that limits itself to enforcing contracts, protecting private property and keeping peace (Nozick’s vision of state – Watchman State)
  • They oppose:-

o   Paternalistic Policies such as wearing of helmet while driving two wheeler
o   Moral legislation such as prohibition of abortion
o   Redistribution of wealth or income

  • Nozick rejects the idea that a just distribution consists of a certain pattern-such as equal income, or equal utility, or equal provision of basic needs and rather focuses on how such distribution came into existence.
  • Nozick argues that distributive justice depends on two requirements:-

o   Justice in initial holdings – if the resources you used to make your money were legitimately yours in the first place. (should not be stolen or taken by force or fraud)
o   Justice in transfer – if you made your money either through free exchanges in the marketplace or from gifts voluntarily bestowed upon you by others.

  • For Nozick, if above two requirements are met one is entitled to what he is and cannot be deprived of the same by the state without his consent.
  • He criticizes employment of distributive justice for trying to create equality as it:-

o   Needs repeated intervention in the free market to undo the effects of the choices people make
o   It violates the rights of those whose wealth is being taken away

  • Taxation of earnings from labour is on a par with forced labour.
  • Based on concept of self-ownership
  • If an individual owns himself then he owns his labour and accordingly also the fruits of his labour

Continue reading about other Jurisprudence topics by clicking here. Grab your notes for other law subjects from here.


Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *